My Husband Came Home with Another Woman and Said

She’d Be His Second Wife—What Surprised Us Both Was My One Condition

7 hours ago

0 761 1 minute read

When my husband Jack came home one day with a woman named Claire and announced she would be his second wife, I thought it was a joke. But when I realized he was serious, I agreed—on one condition he never saw coming.

It all started a few months earlier when Jack began acting strangely. He talked about “alternative lifestyles” and spent an unusual amount of time on his phone, often smiling or chuckling to himself. I assumed it was just another one of his passing fads, like when he obsessed over woodworking or wanted to start a food truck.

Then came the hints. One evening, he said it would be nice to have extra help around the house. When I joked about hiring a cleaning service, he didn’t answer. His tone was serious, and I felt uneasy but didn’t press.

Fast forward to last week: Jack walked in with Claire trailing behind him. Calmly, he introduced her and declared she would be his second wife. I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. Jack said it was a practical arrangement—

Claire would help with cooking, cleaning, and chores, and it was better than sneaking around with a mistress. I stood there, stunned, while Claire avoided my gaze. Then an idea struck me. I smiled and said, “Fine. You can have a second wife—but only if I get a second husband.”

Jack was speechless. When I explained that if he wanted to live in a ‘traditional’ polygamous way, I would have the same right, he tried to argue it was impossible and culturally unacceptable. I reminded him that was selective tradition and refused to back down.

Claire quickly left, and Jack begged me to reconsider. But by then, I had already created a dating profile to find my “second husband,” and I told Jack I was done.

The next morning, Jack admitted it was a terrible idea and wanted to forget the whole thing. But I had made up my mind. I packed my bags, moved out, and filed for divorce. Claire stopped answering his calls, and Jack was left to deal with the fallout of his so-called “practical” plan.